The Justice Project

Letter from Prosecutors, Law Enforcement Officers, and Justice Department Officials to Congress

May 30, 2004

Dear Members of Congress,

The undersigned individuals are current and former prosecutors, law enforcement officers, and Justice Department officials who have served at the state and federal levels. Some of us support capital punishment and others of us oppose it. But we are united in our support for the federal Innocence Protection Act.

Capital cases present unique challenges to our judicial system. The stakes are higher than in other criminal trials and the legal issues are often more complex. When the government seeks a death sentence, it must afford the defendant every procedural safeguard to assure the reliability of the fact-finding process. As prosecutors, we feel a special obligation to ensure that the capital punishment system is fair and accurate.

The Innocence Protection Act seeks to improve the administration of justice by ensuring the availability of post-conviction DNA testing in appropriate cases, and would establish standards for the appointment of capital defense attorneys. The interests of prosecutors are served if defendants have access to evidence that may establish innocence, even after conviction, and if they are represented by competent lawyers.

For these reasons, we are pleased to endorse the Innocence Protection Act. Please feel free to contact any of us to discuss this matter.

Mr. William Aronwald
Former Asst. District Attorney
New York County
Former Asst. US Attorney and Chief, Criminal Division
Eastern District New York
Former Attorney-in-Charge, Organized Crime and Racketeering Strike Force
Southern District New York

Mr. Francis X. Bellotti
Former US Attorney
Commonwealth of Massachusetts

Mr. William M. Bennett
District Attorney
Hampden County, MA

Mr. Matthew Bettenhausen
Deputy Governor, Criminal Justice & Public Safety
State of Illinois
Former Asst. US Attorney

Mr. William G. Broaddus, Esq.
Former Attorney General
Commonwealth of Virginia

Mr. David B. Bukey
Former Acting US Attorney
Milwaukee, WI
Former Asst. US Attorney
Milwaukee, WI and Seattle, WA

Mr. Robert Bundy
Former US Attorney
State of Alaska

Mr. Arnold I. Burns
Former Deputy Attorney General
Department of Justice

Mr. Zachary Carter
Former US Attorney and Deputy Cheif Criminal Division
Eastern District of NY
Former Asst. District Attorney
Kings County, NY
Former Judge
Criminal Court of the City of NY

Mr. J. William Codinha
Former Special Asst. Attorney General
Commonwealth of Massachusetts
Former First Asst. District Attorney
Middlesex County, MA

Mr. W.J. Michael Cody
Former Attorney General
State of Tennessee

Hon. W. Thomas Dillard
Former US Magistrate
Former US Attorney
Northern District Florida

Mr. Tyrone C. Fahner
Former Attorney General
State of Illinois

Mr. Lee Fisher
Former Attorney General
State of Ohio

Mr. Howard W. Goldstein
Former Asst. US Attorney and Chief Appellate Attorney
Southern District of New York

Mr. Timothy M. Gunning
Former Asst. State’s Attorney
Baltimore County, MD

Mr. Terence Hallinan
District Attorney
City & County of San Francisco, CA

Mr. Scott Harshbarger
Former Attorney General
Commonwealth of Massachusetts

Hon. Phillip Heymann
Former Deputy Attorney General
Department of Justice

Mr. Charles Hynes
District Attorney
Kings County, NY

Ms. Gaynelle Griffin Jones
Former US Attorney
Southern District Texas

Mr. Thomas R. Kane
Former Asst. State’s Attorney
Baltimore City, MD

Hon. Gerald Kogan
Chief Justice
Florida Supreme Court (ret.)

Mr. William J. Kunkle, Jr.
Former Prosecutor
DuPage County, IL

Mr. Jim E. Lavine
Former Asst. State’s Attorney
Cook County, IL
Former Asst. District Attorney
Harris County, TX

Hon. Robert S. Litt
Former Principal Assoc. Deputy Attorney General
Department of Justice

Mr. Jeremy Margolis
Former Director
Illinois State Police
Former Asst. US Attorney

Mr. Ralph C. Martin, II
Former District Attorney
Suffolk County, MA

Hon. Jim Mattox
Former Member of Congress
Fifth District, Texas
Former Attorney General
State of Texas

Mr. E. Michael McCann
District Attorney
Milwaukee County, WI

Ms. Randi McGinn
Former Asst. District Attorney, Violent Crimes
Barnalillo County, Albuqurque, NM

Mr. Thomas K. McQueen
Former US Attorney
Northern District Illinois
Former Asst. US Attorney
Deputy Chief, Criminal Litigation Division

Mr. Robert M. Morgenthau
District Attorney
New York County, NY

Mr. William L. Murphy
District Attorney
Richmond County, NY

Hon. Irvin Nathan
Former Assoc. Deputy Attorney General
Department of Justice

Mr. Charles M. Oberly, III
Former Attorney General
State of Delaware

Ms. Phyllis J. Perko
Former Second District Director
Illinois State’s Attorneys Appellate Prosecutor

Ms. Katrina Pfaumer
Former US Attorney
Western District Washington

Mr. Ernie Preate
Former Attorney General
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

Hon. Dom Rizzi
Appellate Court Judge (ret.)
State of Illinois

Hon. Laurie Robinson
Former Asst. Attorney General
Department of Justice

Hon. Jon Schmidt
Former Assoc. Attorney General
Department of Justice

Hon. William S. Sessions
Former Director
Federal Bureau of Investigations
Former Chief US District Judge
Western District of Texas
Former US Attorney
Western District of Texas

Mr. Alan Silber
Former Asst. Prosecutor and Chief, Fraud Section
Essex County, NJ

Mr. Charles B. Sklarsky
Asst. State’s Attorney
Cook County, IL
Former Asst. US Attorney
Northern District Illinois

Mr. Neal R. Sonnett
Former Asst. US Attorney and Chief, Criminal Division
Southern District Florida

Mr. Thomas J. Spota
District Attorney
Suffolk County, NY

Mr. Harry Tervalon, Jr
Former Asst. District Attorney
Orleans Parish, LA
Former Police Officer
New Orleans, LA

Hon. Harold R. Tyler, Jr.
Former Deputy Attorney General
Department of Justice

Mr. Keith Uhl
Former Asst. US Attorney
Southern District Iowa
US Special Prosecutor
Wounded Knee Litigation

Ms. Beth A. Wilkinson
Former Special Attorney for the Attorney General
Department of Justice


Return to the Testimony and Statements Archive